$5 Million In Punitive Damages Awarded To Widow In Bed Sore Case Against Nursing Home & Hospital

A Philadelphia jury awarded $5 million in punitive damages to the widow of a man who died from bed sores he developed during a hospitalization and then worsened during a subsequent nursing home admission.  The case, believed to be the first of its kind in terms of awarding punitive damages against a nursing home in Philadelphia courts, was allocated: $1.5 million against Jeanes Hospital and $3.5 million against Hillcrest Convalescent Home

According to widow's lawyer, Steven R. Maher, Jeans Hospital failed to diagnose the man's urinary tract infection that contributed to the development of bed sores (also referred to as: pressure sores, pressure ulcers or decubitus ulcers) and then the man was transferred to Hillcrest Nursing Home where the bed sores worsened.  Despite his wife's best efforts to care for her husband at home, the man succumbed to the bed sores approximately two years after he developed them.

This punitive damage award is in addition to a $1 million compensatory damage award a jury had previously awarded in the case.   Incidentally, Jeanes Hospital is part of the Temple University Health System and Hillcrest is owned by Genesis HealthCare Corp., a large nursing home operator in the Northeast.

While punitive damages are rare due to the high threshold an injured party must prove, in this case 'outrageous and reckless conduct', it doesn't surprise me that these type of damages were awarded in a bed sore case.  Obviously, the plaintiff's lawyers did a great job presenting their case, but when jurors hear and see how devastating a bed sore can be, it most definitely evokes feelings of rage-- when they see how a medical facilities neglect resulted in such devastating injuries.

Related:

Unusual damages set in Phila, bedsores case, Philly.com, March 17, 2010

Over 500,000 Adults Suffer From Bed Sores In Hospitals

New York Jury Punishes Nursing Home Where Man Develops More Than 20 Bed Sores

If a lawsuit or claim is filed against a facility where a person developed bed sores, what type of damages is the person entitled to?

Bed Sore Pictures, Bed Sore FAQ

Despite Their Avoidability, Bed Sores Continue To Plague Nursing Home & Hospital Patients In All Demographics

Although the news regarding the horrific physical and emotional impact of bed sores (also called decubitus ulcers, pressures sores or pressure ulcers) surely is on all respectable medical professionals radar screens, bed sores in nursing homes and hospitals continue to plague individuals in all demographics.  In order to improve patient care, bed sore prevention must be a priority at all nursing homes and hospitals.

Should a bed sore develop, staff must be diligent in identifying the wound as quickly as possible an implement the use of medical equipment such as pressure relieving mattresses  and other pressure relief devices such as heel protectors to prevent the wounds from advancing.

When bed sore are not timely treated, the wounds may progress and become an advanced stage bed sore. A stage 3 or 4 bed sore typically requires more aggressive interventional medical treatment may be required such as surgical debridementflap reconstruction or a diverting colostomy may be necessary.

By the time significant medical treatment his utilized, many patients are already suffering from complications such as: osteomyelitis, amyloidosis, gangrene or sepsis

In addition to the pain that accompanies bed sores, the medical complications may claim the life of the person.  In my practice, we commonly represent families in wrongful death lawsuits for people who have developed bed sore during an admission to a hospital or nursing home.

Many of these commonly encountered situations are discussed at BedSoreFAQ.com, where we receive thousands of visits every month from concerned family members and care givers. If you have a question, not discussed, feel free to contact me for a no-obligation consultation. (888) 424-5757. Toll-free. Anywhere

Temp Workers Becoming An Increasing Threat To Nursing Home Patients' Safety

As if we need another reason to be concerned over nursing home patient safety, an article in the L.A. Times on temporary nurses in hospitals and nursing homes will surely make you cringe.  A desire to run a streamlined operation and the inherent uncertainly of required staffing levels has resulted in a booming temporary staffing industry-- in particular with nurses.

Unregulated and widely unknown, there are an estimated 3,000 to 6,000 temp. agencies in what is believed to be an industry that takes in more than $4 billion per year--- and growing.  

Though there are certainly many highly qualified and responsible nurses who eagerly accept jobs via temp agencies due to the flexibility and generous pay and benefits, there is a noticeable group of nurses working at temp companies that pose an immediate threat to patients.

An investigation by the non-profit group ProPublica and the Los Angels Times, found many nurses were hired without any background or license checks.  In particular, the investigation revealed nurses who had many problems with prior jobs, caring for the sick and elderly.  

  • Temp firms hired nurses with criminal backgrounds including: prostitution, stealing drugs and possession of cocaine
  • Nurses who had their licenses suspended or restricted in other states were hired by temp firms
  • Even after medical facilities continually complained about a nurses performance (nurses who made errors and fell asleep on the job), the nurse was placed at another facility
  • Nurses who were terminated at one agency were quickly hired by another one without any questioning as to why they left the first agency

No surprise, but it always comes down to money

The lack of industry regulation, a national nursing shortage and easy profits (most temp agencies get paid a substantial percentage of the workers salary) does nothing to discourage people with no nursing or health care knowledge to the field.

Our sick and elderly deserve better.  Patients can and should expect that the person who is caring for them is more than a warm body.  Facilities must begin to demand that the full background checks be conducted on the fresh faces working in their facilities.  On a regional and national level, elected officials must propose legislation to regulate this growing industry.  Unfortunately, until these changes are made, we will continue to see preventable errors contribute to injury and death of patients. 

Resources:

Temp firms a magnet for unfit nurses, With scant regulation and some agencies' poor screening, workers can hopscotch from job to job. L.A. Times, December 6, 2009

Health Care Worker Registry, Nursing Homes Abuse Blog, June 27, 2008

Bye Bye Criminals, Nursing Homes Abuse Blog, June 1, 2008

Failure To Conduct Adequate Pre-Employment Criminal Background Search Costs Assisted Living Facility $750,000, Nursing Homes Abuse Blog, June 5, 2009

Why do nursing homes describe pressure sores according to 'stages'?

"What do nursing homes describe pressure sores according to stages?"

-Edith Phoenix, AZ

Nursing homes and hospitals use a four stage scale to describe, monitor and treat pressure sores (also called bed sores, pressure ulcers or decubitus ulcers).  By categorizing pressure sores, according to standardized characteristics, a sense of uniformity can be established amongst all medical facilities that treat people with pressure sores.

Bed sores are categorized based on their severity (stage 1, stage 2, stage 3 or stage 4). The National Pressure Ulcer Advisory Panel, a professional organization dedicated to the prevention and treatment of bed sores, has set forth specific characteristics to help medical professionals objectively categorize a wound.

Stage I- Initially, a pressure sore appears as a persistent area of red skin that may itch or hurt and feel warm and spongy or firm to the touch. In blacks, Hispanics and other people with darker skin, the mark may appear to have a blue or purple cast, or look flaky or ashen. Stage I wounds are superficial and go away shortly after the pressure is relieved.

Stage II- At this point, some skin loss has already occurred — either in the epidermis, the outermost layer of skin, in the dermis, the skin’s deeper layer, or in both. The wound is now an open sore that looks like a blister or an abrasion, and the surrounding tissues may show red or purple discoloration. If treated promptly, stage II sores usually heal fairly quickly.

Stage III- By the time a pressure ulcer reaches this stage, it has extended through all the skin layers down to the muscle, damaging or destroying the affected tissue and creating a deep, crater-like wound.

Stage IV- In the most serious and advanced stage, a large-scale loss of skin occurs, along with damage to muscle, bone, and even supporting structures such as tendons and joints. Stage IV wounds are extremely difficult to heal and can lead to lethal infections.

Occasionally, a bed sore may be categorized as ‘unstageable‘. Unstageable bed sores are usually referred to as an extremely advanced wound where there is involvement of skin, muscle and bone.

Immobile patients in nursing homes, hospitals, and other medical facilities are particularly at risk for developing bed sores. 
 
If you use a wheelchair, you’re most likely to develop a pressure sore on: your tailbone or buttocks, shoulder blades and spine. Although less common, long-term use of a wheelchair can result in bed sores on the backs of your arms and legs where they rest against the chair.

Bed-bound patients commonly develop pressure sores in the following areas: back or sides of your head, rims of ears, shoulders, hip bones, lower back or tailbone, knees, heels, ankles and toes.

Stages of bed sores

 Resource:

Bed Sore FAQ

National Pressure Ulcer Advisory Panel

Autopsies May Help Families Determine If Their Loved One Was A Victim Of Nursing Home Neglect Or Abuse

Deciding whether to have an autopsy performed on a loved one is indeed a very personal decision for a family to make following a death.  An autopsy can help a family get answers to not only the cause of death, and in the case of potential nursing home negligence, what-- if any, errors may have been made by a medical facility that may have caused the death.

After reading this news article about how a disabled nursing home patient may have 'choked to death' on his lunch I was reminded by how valuable autopsies can be where a death may occur in a nursing home or hospital setting that is insulated from the public.

What is an autopsy?

An autopsy is a detailed medical examination of the person's body and organs following death to establish the specific cause.  Autopsies are performed by a physician, a pathologist, who is trained to evaluate results from physical examinations and laboratory results from tissue and blood samples to determine the cause of death.

Once the examination and laboratory results have been evaluated, an autopsy report is rendered. The report notes the physical findings and states a cause(s) of death.  Because the report is rendered from an impartial author, it can be particularly useful in a litigation setting.  Similarly, just a the report may be useful in case against a nursing home or hospital, results may also absolve the facility of responsibility if the results do not substantiate poor care. 

In order to secure the most accurate results, most pathologists suggest performing an autopsy 24 to 48-hours after the death of a person.  Depending on where the death occurred  and the circumstances surrounding it, the autopsy may be performed by the state medical examiner or by a physician at a private hospital.

Is an autopsy called for in cases where nursing home neglect may have occurred?

In my opinion, particularly in cases involving the elderly, autopsies can be extremely helpful in rebutting arguments made by facilities who may argue that a death was the result of 'old age' or due to a 'variety complicated medical factors'.

Autopsies can be particularly helpful in the following wrongful death matters:

If you wish to have an autopsy performed on a loved one, you should contact your coroner or local hospital to get information about facilities that can perform one at your request.

Related Nursing Homes Abuse Blog Entries

Autopsy Confirms Man Was Murdered In Chicago Nursing Home

Medical Examiner Rules Tennessee Nursing Home Death A Homicide

Grandson Alleges Poor Nursing Care Results In Bed Sores "You Could Stick Your Fist" In

How do I get a copy of medical records from a nursing home?

"How do I get a copy of medical records from a nursing home?"

- Rhonda P., Sacramento, CA

One of the most important steps in determining if a cause of action exists against a nursing home or hospital is to review the medical records.  The records will help determine what-- if any-- mistakes were made by the facility in the care of the individual.

Getting medical records from a nursing home, physician or hospital can be a daunting task due to privacy regulations (HIPPA) and misunderstanding of the laws that apply to obtaininging the records-- both on the part of the person requesting the records and on the part of the medical facility.

Nonetheless, federal and state laws ensure patients and their authorized representatives are entitled get copies of medical records when the laws are complied with. This includes the right to inspect and copy the resident’s clinical records and other records regarding the resident’s care and maintenance that are kept by the facility or by the resident’s physician. (Illinois Nursing Home Care Act - 210 ILCS 25/2-104

A resident’s contract with a nursing home facility should designate the name of the resident’s representative, if any, which authorizes the representative to inspect and copy the resident’s records. (210 ILCS 45/2-202) Nursing home residents also have the right to privacy regarding the content of resident records. 

When a nursing home survey is performed at a facility, the Illinois Department of Health will respect resident confidentiality and not disclose the contents of a record in a manner which identifies a resident, except upon a resident’s death to a relative or guardian or under judicial proceedings. Also, any confidential medical, social, personal, or financial information identifying a resident will not be made available for public inspection in a manner which identifies a resident. (210 ILCS 45/2-206

 

In some states, such as Illinois, a nursing home resident has the right to sue the facility in court in order to get his or her medical records. Illinois law provides that every private and public health care facility must allow a patient or patient’s legal representative to examine the health care facility records kept in connection with the treatment of the patient (history, bedside notes, charts, pictures and plates) and make copies of such records. 

A request for copies of the records must be in writing and delivered to the administrator or manager of the health care facility or to the health care practitioner. The person requesting copies will reimburse the facility for all reasonable expenses. The health care facility must respond to a written request within 30 days of the receipt of the written request. If the facility needs more time to comply, the facility must provide the requesting party a written statement of the reasons for the delay and the date by which the requested information will be provided. In any case, the facility must provide the requested information no later than 60 days after receiving the request. (735 ILCS 5/8-2001

Federal law also provides that the resident or the resident’s legal representative has the right to access all records including clinical records within 24 hours and receive photocopies for a standard charge. (42 CFR §483 – Resident’s rights) The resident also has the right to personal privacy and confidentiality of all personal records. As such, the resident may approve or refuse the release of personal and clinical records to any individual outside the facility unless resident is transferred to another health care institution or release is required by law. 

Tips:

  • Do not tell the facility why you are requesting the records
  • Keep copies of all record requests
  • Send the request via a method to confirm the facility has received the request
  • Request the records as soon as you believe you may be interested in getting them
  • If you are an authorized representative, attach a copy of any relevant paperwork granting such authority to do so
  • Always request a complete copy of the chart

Sources:

Illinois Nursing Home Care Act

Your Medical Record Rights in Illinois

Federal Law – 42 CFR §483 – Resident’s rights.

 

 Applicable sections of IL Nursing Home Care Act:

210 ILCS 45/1-104 – “Access” means the right to: (4) Inspect the clinic and other records of a resident with the express written consent of the resident.

210 ILCS 25/2-104 - (d) Every resident, resident’s guardian, or parent if the resident is a minor shall be permitted to inspect and copy all his clinical and other records concerning his care and maintenance kept by the facility or by his physician. The facility may charge a reasonable fee for duplication of a record. 

210 ILCS 45/2-201. To protect the resident’s funds, the facility: – (3) Shall maintain and allow, in order of priority, each resident or the resident’s guardian, if any, or the resident’s representative, if any, or the resident’s immediate family member, if any, access to a written record of all financial arrangements and transactions involving the individual resident’s funds. 

210 ILCS 45/2-202. – (h) – The contract shall designate the name of the resident’s representative, if any. The resident shall provide the facility with a copy of the written agreement between the resident and the resident’s representative which authorizes the resident’s representative to inspect and copy the resident’s records and authorizes the resident’s representative to execute the contract on behalf of the resident required by this Section. 

210 ILCS 45/2-206. – (a) The Department shall respect the confidentiality of a resident’s record and shall not divulge or disclose the contents of a record in a manner which identifies a resident, except upon a resident’s death to a relative or guardian, or under judicial proceedings. This Section shall not be construed to limit the right of a resident to inspect or copy the resident’s records. (b) Confidential medical, social, personal, or financial information identifying a resident shall not be available for public inspection in a manner which identifies a resident.

210 ILCS 45/2-217. Order for transportation of resident by ambulance. If a facility orders transportation of a resident of the facility by ambulance, the facility must maintain a written record that shows (i) the name of the person who placed the order for that transportation and (ii) the medical reason for that transportation. The facility must maintain the record for a period of at least 3 years after the date of the order for transportation by ambulance.

210 ILCS 45/3-801.1. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Act to the contrary, the agency designated by the Governor under Section 1 of “An Act in relation to the protection and advocacy of the rights of persons with developmental disabilities, and amending Acts therein named”, enacted by the 84th General Assembly, shall have access to the records of a person with developmental disabilities who resides in a facility, subject to the limitations of this Act. The agency shall also have access for the purpose of inspection and copying, to the records of a person with developmental disabilities who resides in any such facility if (1) a complaint is received by such agency from or on behalf of the person with a developmental disability, and (2) such person does not have a guardian or the State or the designee of the State is the guardian of such person. The designated agency shall provide written notice to the person with developmental disabilities and the State guardian of the nature of the complaint based upon which the designated agency has gained access to the records. No record or the contents of any record shall be redisclosed by the designated agency unless the person with developmental disabilities and the State guardian are provided 7 days advance written notice, except in emergency situations, of the designated agency's intent to redisclose such record, during which time the person with developmental disabilities or the State guardian may seek to judicially enjoin the designated agency's redisclosure of such record on the grounds that such redisclosure is contrary to the interests of the person with developmental disabilities. If a person with developmental disabilities resides in such a facility and has a guardian other than the State or the designee of the State, the facility director shall disclose the guardian's name, address, and telephone number to the designated agency at the agency's request. Upon request, the designated agency shall be entitled to inspect and copy any records or other materials which may further the agency's investigation of problems affecting numbers of persons with developmental disabilities. When required by law any personally identifiable information of persons with a developmental disability shall be removed from the records. However, the designated agency may not inspect or copy any records or other materials when the removal of personally identifiable information imposes an unreasonable burden on the facility. For the purposes of this Section, "developmental disability" means a severe, chronic disability of a person which ‑     (A) is attributable to a mental or physical impairment or combination of mental and physical impairments; (B) is manifested before the person attains age 22; (C) is likely to continue indefinitely; (D) results in substantial functional limitations in 3 or more of the following areas of major life activity: (i) self-care, (ii) receptive and expressive language, (iii) learning, (iv) mobility, (v) self-direction, (vi) capacity for independent living, and (vii) economic self-sufficiency; and (E) reflects the person's need for combination and sequence of special, interdisciplinary or generic care, treatment or other services which are of lifelong or extended duration and are individually planned and coordinated. 


Reducing Decubitus Ulcers In Hospitals. How One Facility Managed To Reduce Hospital-Acquired Wounds By 63%

Texas Arlington Memorial Hospital was recently recognized for implementing a systematic program to reduce the number of patients with hospital-acquired decubitus ulcers.  The program resulted in a 63% reduction in pressure sores.  This hospital accomplished this by taking the following steps:

  • Identifying decubitus ulcers on all new admissions
  • Reducing use of diapers amongst patients
  • Encouraging all staff to look for and document decubitus ulcers, even in their earliest stages
  • Paying extra attention to patients who are bed bound or who's skin comes into contact with medical equipment like oxygen masks or tubing
  • Implementing daily skin checks and intensive, hospital-wide skin checks on a quarterly basis to help the facility keep accurate tabs on how well its wound prevention program is working

Related Nursing Homes Abuse Blog Entries

Over 500,000 Adults Suffer From Bed Sores In Hospitals

Pressure Sores In Hospitals On The Rise

In For Rehab. Out With Bedsores.

Proper Wound Documentation

Nursing Home Neglect: What An Advanced Pressure Sore Looks Like

A colleague sent me this disturbing video of an advanced pressure sore.  A fair warning, this video is graphic and disturbing.  However, the reality is that pressure sores are a problem effecting individuals in nursing homes, hospitals, and long-term care facilities and can not be ignored.

 

Related Nursing Homes Abuse Blog Posts Related To Pressure Sores:

Nursing Homes With Higher Percentage Of Hispanic Residents Have Higher Rate Of Bed Sores

New Jersey Orders Use Of Pressure Relieving Mattresses In Nursing Homes

Pressure Sores In Hospitals On The Rise

Hospital Cited For Multiple Safety Violations During Investigation Of Resident Death

The failure of a Pennsylvania hospital to take basic steps to protect its patients may have cost a dementia patient her life.  89-year-old Rose Lee Diggs was admitted to UPMC Montefiore for multiple deficiencies during the investigation of her death.  Although Diggs was transferred from a nursing home that warned the hospital of her propensity to wander, staff at the hospital failed to take any preventative measures to assure Diggs safety in their facility.

Five days after Diggs admission to UPMC she was found dead on the hospital roof in her hospital gown and slippers in 20-degree temperatures.  The Pennsylvania Department of Health determined Diggs was able to access the rooftop through a mechanical room with a broken lock.  The last recorded sighting of Diggs by hospital staff was more than 13 hours before her body was discovered. 

The health department's investigation into the death determined the hospital acted improperly when it:

  • Failed to assess patients safe care needs
  • Failed to take any steps to address wandering behavior- despite the nursing home advised them of this tendency
  • Failed to maintain a safe hospital environment

Following the health department's report, the hospital developed a plan of correction to address the deficiencies.  Among the new programs initiated: a 'Condition L' plan that causes all hospital employees to help in a coordinated search for missing residents, geriatric or psychiatric nurses are to conduct specific assessments of each patients propensity to wander and a policy to inspect doors leading to outside areas.

The family of Diggs is planning to pursue a civil case against the hospital for their negligent care that caused or contributed to her death.  This matter highlights the importance of investigations by health departments into situations involving negligent care in hospitals and nursing homes.  Frequently, the information obtained by investigators can be helpful in the course of litigation as witness statements and other valuable information is captured shortly after the incident took place.

Related article

State cites UPMC for patient's death on roof

Pressure Sores In Hospitals On The Rise

An increasing number of number of pressure sore cases my office is working on involve pressure sores that have developed during a hospitalization.  What was once considered a sad symbol of poor nursing home care, is now increasingly associated with poor hospital care.  Many of our clients who enter a hospital for acute care, wind up extending their hospitalization due to the development of a pressure sore during their stay. 

Federal and State regulations require nursing homes to conduct a thorough assessment of all new admissions.  The assessment evaluates the individuals skin integrity and attempts to determine who is susceptible to develop of pressure sores.  This initial assessment is designed to help nursing home staff implement preventative pressure sore care.

Hospitals on the other hand, are not governed by the same regulations and consequently are not as attuned to pressure sore prevention.  Many hospitals fail to train their staff to identify pressure sore risk and implement policies for pressure sore prevention.

According to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), the number of hospital patients who develop pressure sores (also known as pressure ulcers, bed sores or decubitus ulcers) has increased by 63% since 1996. 

Pressure sores are caused by unrelieved pressure to the skin which cuts off blood circulation to the area.  Hospitalized seniors are particularly vulnerable to development of pressure sores because many have limited mobility and may be bedridden.  Further increasing the risk of pressure sores amongst the elderly is the fact that many seniors have lost a considerable amount of muscle and fat that would normally help relieve the pressure in younger people.  Most pressure sores develop in areas where there is a 'bony' prominence.  Common areas where pressure sores develop are: the sacrum, coccyx, heels, elbows and ankles. 

Pressure sores are graded by their severity (1, 2, 3 and 4).  A stage 1 pressure sore may be a reddened area with some blistering.  By the time a pressure sore advances to stage 4, a deep wound has developed and may also involve organs and bones.  The AHRQ determined the average duration of a hospital stay for treatment of pressure sores to be 13 days, with an average cost of $37,500.

Pressure sores are preventable.  Hospital staff need to focus on patients factors and take necessary steps to assure patients remain free from pressure sores during their stay.  Among the steps hospitals need to take to prevent development of pressure sores are:

  • Changes resident's positioning every two hours
  • Use pressure relieving air mattresses
  • Make sure patients are receiving proper nutrition
  • Keep the resident clean and dry

We can help you

Don't let hospitals get away with providing substandard care. If you or a loved one has developed a pressure sore during a hospitalization, put our experience litigating pressure sore cases to work for you.  We have successfully recovered money for our clients from hospitals throughout the country. Contact the pressure sore lawyers at Strellis & Field for a personalized case consultation. All consultations are confidential.   We will come to you. 

Resource: About.com