Nursing Home Spotlight: Addolorata Villa: Wheeling, Illinois

Even at nursing home facilities with relatively high Medicare ratings and low average number of health deficiencies, serious problems can still occur. Despite a three-star (average Medicare rating), Addolorata Villa (a nursing home located in Wheeling, Illinois with 91 certified beds) failed to provide proper care and services to an elderly female resident after a fall, which then required an ER visit for serious injuries. 

Addolorata received two stars for its health inspections for five health deficiencies over the past year. This is three less health deficiencies than the average number of health deficiencies for Illinois nursing homes and also three less than the average number of health deficiencies for United States nursing homes. Despite the average rating, this facility still suffers from serious health deficiencies, which resulted in serious injuries. 

In March 2009, Addolorata Villa failed to properly monitor a resident after a fall and also failed to properly notify the attending physician of a change in condition. The resident ended up in the ER with a brain bleed and fracture because of these failures. Elderly residents are particularly susceptible to falls because of weakness, illness, and balance problems. 

On March 24, 2009, an 83 year old female resident suffering from Dementia fell from her chair directly across from the nurse’s station. The resident suffered facial lacerations, swelling, and bruising. The nurse assessed the resident, returned her to the chair, and administered first aid. 

Facility staff continued to monitor the resident who denied pain despite restlessness, agitation, grimacing (which is a symptom of pain) and continued swelling and bruising of her left eye, which progressed to the extent that the staff was unable to open her eye to check the eye and pupil response. However, on the morning of March 26, the resident was noted to be more lethargic and was sent to the emergency room (ER) for evaluation. The resident was then admitted to the hospital with a brain bleed and cervical fracture

The facility failed to provide timely, frequent and comprehensive neurological assessments, and also failed to notify the physician in a timely manner of the change in neurological status and change in the condition of the left eye. These failures resulted in a 33 hour delay in medical treatment for the elderly resident. The facility’s failures and neglect resulted in this resident suffering from prolonged pain and further injury, ending in an ER visit. 

Each and every nursing home resident has the right to receive the necessary care and services to attain or maintain the highest practicable physical, mental, and psychosocial well-being. This requirement was not met when the facility failed to provide proper treatment to this resident after her fall. During the following May 7, 2009 complaint investigation, the surveyor found that the facility’s significant failures placed this resident’s health and safety in immediate jeopardy.

When choosing a nursing home facility for a family member, there are many factors that should influence your decision, including the number of residents, number of staff, location, past health deficiencies, Medicare rating. You must be aware that even relatively good facilities with an average Medicare rating can have serious health deficiencies, which can result in serious injuries. 

Sources:

IDPH: Addolorata Villa

Medicare: Addolorata Villa

Chicago Business: Illinois Ranks High on Bad Nursing Home Report  

Nursing Home Cited For Mistreatment Of Resident Following Investigation Of Resident's Fractured Neck

The Minnesota Department of Health released an investigative report concluding a resident of Presbyterian Homes of Arden Hills Nursing Home sustained a broken neck due to a fall or other trauma at the facility.  The investigation follows the death of 91-year-old Gladys Gall, a resident at the facility.  Despite the fact no federal or state nursing home violations were identified, investigators still determined there was ample circumstantial evidence to conclude the nursing home was at fault in the injury and subsequent death of Gall.  On April 18, 2008 Gall was admitted to an emergency room after complaining of head and neck pain.  A CT scan confirmed Gall's pain was related to a cervical fracture. On April 28th, Gall died from complications related to the cervical fracture.

Gall was likely as high fall risk due to memory loss and advanced osteoporosis.  Gall required assistance from nursing home staff for most daily living activities.

Investigators interviewed both Gall's family as well as staff at Alden Hills in attempting to determine the cause of Gall's broken neck.  Additionally, a neurosurgeon was consulted for the state's investigation and verified Gall suffered a hangman's fracture.  Further, the neurosurgeon opined the severity of the hangman's fracture could not have occurred without trauma.  Although no specific traumatic event could be identified as the culprit of the injury, three conclusions were reached in the report:

  • Gall's death was related to her cervical fracture
  • The neck fracture was related to a violent incident or fall
  • Someone at the nursing home was aware of what happened to Gall because she would have been unable to pick herself up following her type of injury

Nursing home officials dispute the state's findings, pointing out the findings were not related to any specific event involving nursing home abuse or maltreatment nor can the report rule out an accident. Read more about this cervical fracture of a Minnesota nursing home resident here.

Nursing Home Falls

Falls are one of the most common sources of injuries amongst nursing home residents.  Despite, claims by nursing home officials that some falls are 'unpreventable', steps can be taken to minimize the risk of falls and related injuries;

  • Identify residents who may be at risk of falling
  • Provide adequate staffing to assist residents with transfers, toileting and general mobility
  • Remove clutter from the floors
  • Encourage residents to use asistive devices
  • Minimize the use of medications that can alter blood pressure

Related Nursing Home Abuse Blog Posts On Falls

$50,000 Penalty Sought Against Nursing Home Where Resident Fell To Her Death

Falls Amongst The Elderly Can't Be Ignored

Hip Fractures And Some Unsettling Statistics

Study Links Medication Use With Falls

Web Resource On Hangman's Fracture

Traumatic Spondylolisthesis of the Axis (Hangman's Fracture), Medscape Today