Poor Nursing Home Care Subject Of Class Action Lawsuit Against National Nursing Home Chain, Extendicare

Extendicare, a nationally known provider of nursing home care has recently been named as a defendant in a class action lawsuit in Minnesota.  The lawsuit alleges that residents of Extendicare Services, Inc. and Extendicare Homes, Inc. engaged in false advertising unconscionable contracts for new residents at their facilities.

With respect to the claim involving false advertising, the lawsuit claims Extendicare deceptively lured elderly persons to their facilities, with advertising campaigns claiming the facilities would be able to provide the individuals with the care they need.  Extendicare's brochures, staff, and website promoted the nursing homes ability to provide high-quality, skilled nursing care as well standards that exceeded those set by the government with respect to nursing homes.

Government regulations require nursing homes and long-term care facilities to conduct a thorough assessment of individual and their medical needs at the time of admission.  In contrast, Extendicare's nursing homes admission policies paid no to the individuals medical condition or the facilities ability to care for the individual. The needs of current residents were similarly ignored as the nursing home attempted to keep their nursing homes filled to the brim without regard to staffing levels or if certain residents required more care than others.

Another part of the class action lawsuit addresses Extendicare's mandated admission contract that requires new residents and their families to limit their rights with respect to bringing a lawsuit against the facility for personal injuries or property damage.  The admission contract is in violation of Minnesota law that forbids nursing homes from imposing on residents constitutional rights.

Extendicare is on a role.  In addition to facing multiple fines for dangerous nursing home conditions and injury lawsuits in Wisconsin, the nursing home chain faces a similar class action lawsuit in Washington.  In Minnesota, Extendicare owned nursing homes consistently received a higher number of violations than the state average.  

This multi-billion dollar corporation needs to be held accountable for its deceptive and injury-causing practices.  Unfortunately, there are many smaller, non-corporate owned nursing homes that provide poor levels of nursing home care.  If you believe, your loved one in in a situation where they are exposed to nursing home abuse or neglect, you should take steps to remove them from the facility immediately.

AARP Joins Fight To Preserve Right To Jury Trial

AARP, filed a 'friend of the court' brief in a wrongful death lawsuit pending in New Mexico.  The brief is intended to provide supplement information to the court regarding an injured nursing home resident's ability to pursue a nursing home negligence lawsuit in court as opposed to binding arbitration as stipulated to in a nursing home admission agreement. 

Roswell Senior Living, the owner of a nursing home in New Mexico filed a motion to dismiss a nursing home negligence lawsuit filed by the family of a deceased nursing home resident.  Roswell claims any disputes involving nursing home injury or death, should be resolving via arbitration as stipulated by admission paperwork. AARP has taken a position, supportive of the family bringing the lawsuit that the arbitration clause should be held invalid because of the unequal bargaining position and an injured person's right to jury trial.

Many unsuspecting nursing home residents sign arbitration agreements when they are admitted to the facility.  Little do they know that should they become injured due to the negligence of the facility they could be forced to forgo their right to a jury trial and damages.  Arbitration's have generally been used to resolve business disputes, behind closed doors in a private forum.  Because no court actually hears the matter, many discovery, evidentary and procedural rights are curtailed.  The curtailment of rights usually adversely impacts the injured party.

Fortunately, many State Courts have recently held these binding arbitration agreements to be invalid, and allow injury nursing home residents to pursue claims for damages in court.  We will keep blog readers posted the outcome of this case.

Nursing Home Injury Laws: New Mexico

Never Event #6: Foreign Objects Left In During Surgery

Incidents involved foreign objects left inside the body during surgery are common occurrence. Statistics from The New England Journal Of Medicine show that most large hospitals will have at least one incident per year where a surgical teams leaves surgical equipment behind.  The most common item left inside body cavities are surgical sponges.  Even larger items have been left inside the body cavity including: scalpels, scissors, tweezers, needles and even parts to a drill. 

Surgeries that require opening of the chest or abdomen have a higher likelihood for the hospital staff leaving foreign objects behind.  There are similar increases in the number of incidents in emergency surgeries, unplanned changes during surgery and in people with higher body mass indexes.

Foreign objects left in the body may remain relatively quiet for years before they are discovered.  Once discovered these foreign objects usually need to be removed.  Foreign objects may become dislodged and cause major injuries such as sepsis, infection, internal bleeding and death.

Why Are Foreign Objects Left During Surgery On The 'Never List'?

Leaving a foreign object in the body during surgery is the result of a sloppy surgical staff.  All members of the operative staff have a responsibility to the patient to assure that all surgical equipment is removed following the procedure.  Hospitals should have preventative policies in effect to reduce or avoid incidents involving foreign objects left in the body:

  • Mandatory surgical sweeps including a visual and manual inspection of the operative area
  • Double counts of all surgical supplies
  • Use of x-ray detectable items in the surgical wound
  • Take x-rays where there is an inability to count the surgical supplies or there is a discrepancy in the count numbers

When To Contact A Nursing Home Attorney?

In situations where there has been a specific incident involving a serious injury or abuse, the nursing home resident themselves or their family will seek out the advice of a nursing home attorney for representation.

The majority of nursing home neglect cases are far more subtle and many people are hesitant to seek out an attorney.  The best rule of thumb is to trust your instinct.  If something doesn't seem right--it's probably not.  Because most cases of nursing home neglect involve ongoing mistreatment, it is important to contact an attorney when you begin to suspect the nursing home may be treating your loved one improperly. 

Pay attention to the physical signs.  Most elderly are hesitant to report situations involving nursing home abuse or neglect and may be scared to confront the people responsible for providing their care.  Patterns of injury should not be tolerated.  Repeated falls, bruising, cuts or infection deserve to to investigated as they are easily preventable situations that are indicative of staffing problems at a facility.

Statute of limitations, or specific time allotments, govern how much time one has to bring a lawsuit against the nursing home or long-term care facility.  Statute of limitations may provide years for pursuing a cause of action.  However, the sooner an attorney is contacted, the sooner an investigation can be started to determine what may have caused the injury or abuse.  Many cases involving nursing home abuse, neglect or injury require the review of extensive medical records and expert witness consultation--time consuming practices to say the least. 

Even in situations where there may seem to be a lack of evidence to prove neglect on the part of the nursing home, an experienced nursing home attorney will be able to sort through the evidence and determine if there is a case and how to proceed.  Most nursing home attorneys work on a contingency fee, meaning they only receive a fee if they are successful in obtaining compensation for the injured party.  No out of pocket expenses are required on behalf of the client. 

There has been a recent trend, in some situations involving severe injury, where the nursing home or hospital may seem to take responsibility for an injury.  Representations may be made by the staff at these facilities that they will 'do whats right' to remedy the situation.  Don't be lulled into believing this song.  Rarely --if ever -- do these individuals really have the interests of the injured party in mind.  Moreover, without the consult of an attorney well versed in what damages an injured person is entitled to receive, the nursing home or hospital will use its uneven bargaining position in its favor.

If you or a loved one suspect the nursing home, long-term care facility, home nurse or hospital may have caused or contributed to an injury or situation involving abuse, why not speak to an attorney who has your interests in mind without any charge to you?

Resource:

Nursing Home Injury Laws

Bad News For Illinois Nursing Home Residents

A study by the American Health Care Association (AHCA) has determined that Medicaid is underfunding state long-term care by a whopping $4.2 billion in 2008.  Obviously, the funding shortfall will necessitate budget cuts that impact Medicaid funding for nursing homes.  According to the AHCA report, New York will be the hardest hit with a projected shortfall of $548.1 million, followed by Illinois with a $379.3 shortfall with Ohio, Pennsylvania and New Jersey filling out the top five. 

Nursing homes are already feeling the financial impact of the of federal funding problems.  According to the Medicare Payment Advisory Committee, the combined average margin to nursing homes by Medicare and Medicaid programs is negative 1.8%.  In other words, for every $100 a nursing home pays, they are only getting reimbursed $98.20. 

How will this nursing home funding crisis affect Illinois nursing home residents?  Clearly, if it hasn't happened already nursing homes will be forced to cut back on programs and staffing to keep their businesses afloat.  This is definitely bad news for all Illinois nursing home residents and their families.

Nursing Homes For Alzheimer's Patients. What To Look For?

The following is a recent article I authored for the Senior Home Care Blog.  Senior Home Care Blog is a valuable source of information for caregivers to people who suffer from Alzheimer's, stroke, MS and other brain impairing conditions.  I highly reccommend this blog as a great resource to all home care providers and nursing home staff.

At some point, most Alzheimer’s patients will spend time in a nursing home or assisted living facility.  Whether, the stay is a temporary or permanent in nature, the special needs of Alzheimer’s patients must be recognized and evaluated before the person is placed into a nursing home environment.  There are no specific nursing home regulations in place for people with Alzheimer’s and dementia.  Consequently, the burden of selecting an appropriate facility falls squarely on the shoulders of the family or close friends.  The following is general ‘game plan’ that can be used by families of people with Alzheimer’s, dementia or traumatic brain injury to aid in the selection of a temporary or permanent nursing home.

Before any change in living arrangements is contemplated, a complete physical and mental assessment of you loved one should be completed.  A candid discussion of the individuals needs should be done in the presence of the family and caregivers.  Try to decide what the person is really capable of an in what areas the person needs assistance. Honesty is crucial.  An open and honest discussion will help with the selection of a facility, but will also help the staff at the facility a baseline get an idea of your loved one’s needs. 

 Initial selection of a nursing home or long-term care facility for an Alzheimer’s patient is no different from the selection of a nursing home for a non-Alzheimer’s patient.  The first step is to do some research about the facilities via friends or on the internet. I suggest the Medicare website (http://www.medicare.gov/NHCompare/Include/DataSection/Questions/SearchCriteria.asp?version=default&browser=Safari%7C2%7CMacOSX&language=English&defaultstatus=0&pagelist=Home&CookiesEnabledStatus=True) as a starting point.  You can see on-line where the facilities are located and what services they offer.

 After conducting some initial fact gathering about the facilities, a visit to the facility is a must.  Do not risk the safety and happiness of your loved one at a facility without physically visiting the facility. Before deciding on a facility at least two visits are in order.  The first visit should be a scheduled visit to get a tour from the staff.  If the initial visit passes muster, a second unannounced visit should be made.  The second visit will likely be more telling than a carefully coordinately tour.  Do not hesitate to talk with the staff during your visits.  You can learn a lot about the facility depending on their attitude and demeanor.  Unhappy staff is usually indicative of unhappy residents.

 Unlike most nursing homes that care for the elderly, nursing homes that care for Alzheimer’s patients and those suffering from a brain injury needs to take precaution to reduce the risk of residents harming themselves and others.  Nursing homes for Alzheimer’s patients should have specialized design considerations to help ensure the individual’s safety and happiness.  Facilities should:

 

-       Place restrictions on in-and-out privileges for residents.  Safeguards to prevent elopement (http://www.nursinghomesabuseblog.com/2008/07/articles/elopement-wandering/elopement/) and wandering (http://www.nursinghomesabuseblog.com/2008/07/articles/elopement-wandering/wandering/)—common sources of injury to Alzheimer’s residents.

-       Require each visitor to sign in.  Mentally impaired residents are disproportionately physically and sexually abused compared with the general nursing home population.

-       Bracelets and alarms.  Does the facility have a tracking system or alarm for residents who have a tendency to wander?  Depending on the mobility of the individual, a surveillance bracelet should be used to keep track of the person.

-       The facility should have clearly marked walkways inside and outsides the facilities. The walkways should be well lit, have directional signage with diagrams as opposed to written diagrams.

-       Have a circular configuration. Alzheimer’s patients get particularly frustrated when encountered by dead-ends and right angles.

Staffing Is The #1 Consideration

‘Does the facility regularly handle people with Alzheimer’s?’  This is an important question to ask, because the most important factor in your loved ones happiness and safety will be dependent on how much experience the facility has in dealing with Alzheimer’s patients.  Seek out a facility that focuses exclusively on Alzheimer’s care or has a specialized unit for residents with Alzheimer’s. If the facility houses both Alzheimer’s and non-Alzheimer’s patients, precautions should be in place to control both groups access to the other.  Though it may seem segregationalist, depending on the level of functionality, most Alzheimer’s patients should be kept together for their own safety.

 Most incidents involving nursing home injury occur due to staffing problems.  Don’t be afraid to ask some or all of the following:

-       Does the facility require / provide any specialized Alzheimer’s training for the staff?

-       Does the facility do backgrounds checks on all employees?

-       What is the policy for alerting a family member to an incident?

-       What is the policy for physical and / or drug restraints?

-       What is the facilities toileting policy? Are diapers changed regularly or does the facility only change on a schedule?

-       How does the facility ensure that resident’s eat?  Do they have staff to monitor what is and is not eaten?

-       What is the resident / staff ratio?  A general rule is 1:6 for staffing during the day.

Jonathan Rosenfeld is a lawyer in Chicago that concentrates his practice in representation of victims of nursing home abuse and neglect throughout the country.  Jonathan author’s the Nursing Homes Abuse Blog.  The blog contains information useful to families of nursing home residents and attempts to answer many frequently encountered questions regarding nursing homes and assisted living facilities. Jonathan is available to discuss all aspects of nursing home care.  You may reach him at Jonathan@rosenfeldinjurylawyers.com or toll-free (888) 424-5757.

Nursing Home Negligence Results In Death Of Nun

A 90-year-old nun who was a resident at Summit Park Hospital and Nursing Care Center in New York died following a head injury when a stand alone closet fell and hit her on the head.  The woman sustained injuries to her head and face.  She was transferred to a local hospital where she succumbed to her injures.

This was the third incident within a year at Summit Park Nursing Home involving similar closets falling and injuring a resident.  Incidents involving injury to nursing home residents must be reported to authorities. However neither of the similar incidents involving falling armoires were reported by the nursing home.

Centers for Medicare and Medicaid fined the facility $17,300 following the incident and the facility faces additional fines imposed by state authorities. New York Health Department spokeswoman, Claire Pospisil, comments, 'They have to take appropriate steps to ensure that this never happens again."

Not only has this nursing home been jeopardizing the safety of its residents, but perhaps even more alarming is the fact that it has chosen to play by its own rules.  If this facility failed to report the two other incidents in which patients were injured with the same armoir type closets, rest assured they are not properly attending to the needs of their residents.  What else is this dangerous nursing home hiding?

Read more about this dangerous nursing home here.

Nursing Home Injury Laws: New York

Dementia Patient Chokes To Death On Ketchup Packet In Nursing Home

Glenwood Gardens, a California retirement community was fined $100,000 by the California Department of Public Health following the death a resident who choked to death on a ketchup packet in 2006.  The 84-year-old man lived at the facilities skilled nursing facility because he suffered from dementia and had breathing difficulties.  The ketchup packet was wedged in the back of the man's throat by a mortuary embalmer.  Investigators determined the staff at the facility were aware of the man's propensity to eat non-edible objects and failed to formulate a plan to prevent the man from ingesting the ketchup packet.  Read more about this incident involving nursing home neglect here.

What makes this incident particularly inexcusable is that it occurred at a facility that concentrates in providing skilled nursing care to Alzheimer's and dementia patients.  It is a common problem for Alzheimer's Had the facility taken the basic precaution of removing non-edible objects from the residents meal tray this incident would likely not have occurred.  Moreover, had the staff properly monitored this man as he ate, the choking should have been caught and the ketchup packet removed from the man's throat.

Glenwood Gardens is part of Brookdale Senior Living communities.  Brookdale is the largest owner and operator of senior living communities in the United States.  Brookdale owns more than 550 senior living and retirement communities and houses more than 50,000 residents.  There are many Brookdale facilities throughout Illinois.

19 Hours In A Hospital Waiting Room... For A Bill

On September 24th, Amber Joy Milbrodt injured her leg while playing volleyball.  Needing medical treatment, Milbrodt went to the emergency room at Parkland Hospital in Dallas, Texas.  After a three and a half hour wait the a nurse provided an initial assessment of Ms. Milbrodt and sent her back to the waiting area.  Fifteen hours later and still sitting in the waiting area, Ms. Milbrodt had enough and went home.  Ms. Milbrodt later visited a chiropractic school where they confirmed that she had a broken leg. Ms. Milbrodt received a bill for the emergency room assessment several days later.

What makes this incident particularly disturbing is that it comes just five days after a man died after waiting 19 hours for relief of his chest pain.  On September 20th, 59-year-old, Mike Herrera, died from cardiac arrest in an examination room in the emergency room.  Mr. Herrera checked himself into the emergency room at a computer kiosk before he began his wait.

Parkland officials acknowledge the problem with patient wait times in the emergency room.  "There's nothing you can say except just apologize for this happening," Parkland's president, Ron Anderson, told reporters after the September 20 death.

 

Mr. Herrera's death follows years of warnings about excessive wait times in the emergency department of Dallas County's charity hospital, which serves the indigent and others without health insurance.  A 2004 study on the hospital – which noted two previous consultant reports – said wait times in Parkland's ER were so excessive that more than one in 10 patients left the hospital before seeing a doctor.

 

Since then, that ratio has increased to one in five. Officials say the hospital simply has too few beds for the crush of people needing care. The emergency department, where 81 percent of the hospital's patients are admitted, is a perpetual logjam.  Last year, patients admitted to the hospital through the ER waited an average of 12 hours and 42 minutes for an inpatient bed. This year, the hospital has shaved an hour from that time.

 

Obviously this facility is in the business of providing inadequate patient care.  Even if the facility is overwhelmed with patients, a person from the hospital must be present to prioritize patient needs. Not tending to cardiac or orthopedic patients in a timely manner is malpractice and the facility should be held fully responsible for the injuries.

 

Read more about the September 20 this incident involving emergency room malpractice here.

How Much Freedom Should Assisted Living Facilities Give The Mentally Disabled?

A mentally and physically disabled woman walked out of an Maple Crest Manor, an assisted living facility in St. Louis, MO,  and unknown to the facility boarded a bus to Chicago, IL.  The woman left the assisted living facility for what the staff suspected would be 'a long walk'.  After several hours passed without sight of the woman, the facility contacted the woman's legal guardian who then alerted police.

Chicago police called local Missouri authorities after finding the woman's name on the national database for missing and endangered people.  The woman was brought by authorities safely back to the facility in St. Louis.  No charges were filed against the assisted living facility or the legal guardian.  

Authorities report the woman has the mental capacity of a 7-year-old.  This begs the question: Would you let your 7-year-old walk around unsupervised?  Clearly, this incident should have been prevented with the adoption of a more restrictive leave policy for residents.  

Read the full story regarding this incident involving elopement at an assisted living facility here.

"The Nursing Home Says My Dad's Bedsores Were Unpreventable..."

A blog reader recently wrote, "The nursing home says my dad's bedsores were unpreventable. Is this the case, or are some bedsores an unavoidable part of living in a nursing home?"

No!  The nursing home is lying to your face is is probably trying to cover their own.  Bedsores, also called pressure sores or decubitus ulcers, are preventable--with proper screening, early detection, and staff involvement.   Bedsores are a widespread problem in nursing homes and hospitals. The development of of bedsores in nursing home patients is really a reflection of poor nursing care than an inevitable part of of the aging process.

Bedsores will likely develop if the nursing home and its staff do not make bedsore prevention a top priority.  Nursing homes must do a thorough assessment of residents on admission and on a regular basis during their stay.  Following the assessment, the nursing home should develop a comprehensive care plan that specifies what precautionary measures should be in place.  
 
Nursing home patients often have mental or physical health conditions that limit their ability to stand, walk, or even turn themselves in bed should be 'flagged' and given necessary intervention to prevent bedsores. Bedridden patients who are incontinent are at high risk of forming bedsores and require regular clothing and bed sheet changes to keep the resident clean and dry.
 
The nursing home plan should include considerations to monitor each resident's:  hydration, nutrition, and hygiene. Early signs of bedsores should be identified by the nursing home staff and treatments should implemented.  Unattended, bedsores can quickly become infected leading to sepsis, limb amputation and even death.
 
As part of nursing home's system of bedsore prevention, nursing home residents (particularly the bed-bound) should be repositioned every two hours and ensuring proper hygiene.  Pressure relieving mattresses should be implemented as a preventative measure.  While bedsore prevention plans are great in theory, the most important part of bedsore prevention and treatment ultimately relies on the skill and dedication of the staff.  Do not let a nursing home or hospital tell you your loved one's bedsore was unpreventable!

'Senior Sitter' Charged With Sexual Assault Of Nursing Home Residents

In a new twist on the widely reported under-staffing in many nursing homes, some families of nursing home residents have chosen to provide supplemental care for their family members by hiring private sitters.  Similar to baby sitters, the senior sitters are intended to provide additional supervision and assistance for individual nursing home residents.  Because these senior sitters are not employees of the nursing homes, they are not regulated or subject to background checks.

The story of a senior sitter, who sexually assaulted several nursing home residents made headlines, recently.  The incident will hopefully increase public awareness about all visitors to nursing homes.  No matter how harmless or well intentioned a visitor may seem, nursing homes must take basic steps to safeguard the well being of their residents.  Nursing homes should not only keep an accurate record of visitors, but they should also keep track of the visitors whereabouts while they are in the facility.  Read more about this sad incident involving sexual assault in a nursing home here.

 

Never Event #5: Deep Vein Thrombosis / Pulmonary Embolism Following Surgery

 What Is Deep Vein Thrombosis?

Deep vein thrombosis (DVT) occurs when a blood clot forms inside the body.  Deep vein thrombosis usually occurs in the legs, arms and chest.  If a blood clot dislodges from the area where it initially formed it may get stuck in a smaller vein and block circulation of blood and cause organ problems. Deep vein thrombosis may cause problems in the lungs, brain, heart or other vital organs.  If not detected quickly, a blood clot may cause permanent damage or death.

Symptoms Of Deep Vein Thrombosis

  • May or may not be detected via manifestation of physical symptoms
  • Tenderness in arms, legs or chest
  • Pain or swelling of arms, legs, chest

Causes Of Deep Vein Thrombosis

  • Surgery or injury that restricts blood flow to a part of the body
  • Inherited conditions that increases blood clotting
  • History of heart attack or stroke
  • Obesity
  • Inactivity for long periods of time

What Is Pulmonary Embolism?

Pulmonary embolism is a sudden blockage of a major artery in the lung.  Generally, the blockage is caused by a blood clot.  The blood clots may cause permanent harm to the lung, but they usually do not cause death.  It is important to diagnose pulmonary embolism quickly to reduce the risk of permanent complications.

Symptoms Of Pulmonary Embolism

  • Shortness of breath
  • Sharp chest pain
  • Mucus that comes up when coughing
  • Sweats
  • Increased heart rate

Causes Of Pulmonary Embolism

  • Inactivity
  • Recent surgery in legs or abdomen
  • Severe infection
  • Obesity
  • Age (there is a higher risk of pulmonary embolism in people over 70)

Why Is Deep Vein Thrombosis And Pulmonary Embolism Following Hip & Knee Surgery On The 'Never Event' list?

First of all, hospital staff should be on the look out to identify the early stages of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism in individuals who recently had hip or knee surgery.  In addition, hospital staff should take some or all of the following measures to reduce the risk of development of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism by:

  • Starting patients on blood thinners
  • Encouraging activity as soon as feasible following surgery
  • Giving patients extra fluid
  • Using compression stockings
  • Limiting the use of some medications which have been linked to blood clotting problems: Vioxx, Bextra and Celebrex

If you or a loved one have are scheduled for any type of othropedic surgery, discuss with your doctor the need for prophylactic treatment.  If you have suffered a deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism following hip or knee surgery, contact a medical malpractice attorney to learn if you have a potential claim against the hospital or physician.

Is There A Difference Between A DNR Order And 'Do Not Treat Order'?

I have been getting some really good questions from blog readers.  Some are very unique, most are questions that consistently arise in cases involving nursing home abuse and neglect.  I have added a new 'Frequently Asked Questions' category to blog to hopefully provide an easy source to reference information.  

I will be periodically be posting more questions and responses.  No full names will be used to protect the identity of blog readers.  Further, I encourage you to contact me to discuss your specific situation. Many questions may seem similar, but as cliche as it sounds, every case is really unique.  

----------------------------------

 

"What are the legal aspects if a nurse treats a DNR as a Do Not Treat document? If a person has a correctable problem and fails to treat it or notify the doctor, because they have a DNR status? I am doing a research paper and I need documentation for at least an answer to this question. Please Email me soon if you can help. Thank You, Amie"

 

 

Amie-

As far as I am concerned, there really is no such thing as a 'do not treat order'.  A 'do not treat order' amounts to physicians and nurses withholding medical treatment for a treatable medical condition. A DNR applies the use of artificial, life-prolonging medical treatment when a person has a terminal disease or is in the end-stage of life. 

If a nurse fails to provide treatment or notify a doctor for a correctable problem because the patient has a DNR order in their chart, the facility is responsible for the fallout.  The nurse is clearly ignoring the intent of DNR orders.  (Because the nurses are employees of the nursing homes, the nursing home is responsible for the acts of their agents)

There have been situations recently that I am aware of in nursing homes where the facilities have been hit with huge verdicts / entered into large settlements for withholding medical treatment that resulted in death.  There was a recent Florida case where the nursing home settled a case for roughly 10 million when the staff let a woman bleed to death following a fall in the facility.  The nurses misinterpreted a DNR order as 'do not treat'.

Hope this helps.  Good luck on the paper.  Let me know if you have further questions.

Jonathan Rosenfeld

 

Have You Suffered An Injury After Taking Avandia?

 What is Avandia?

Avandia is the most commonly prescribed diabetes drug in the United States.  Avandia (rosiglitazone) is used to treat type 2, non-insulin dependent diabetes by increasing the bodies sensitivity to insulin. Avandia is manufactured by pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline and has been on the market since 1999.  If you have type 2, diabetes there is a strong likelihood you may have taken Avandia at some time.

What Type Of Adverse Side Effects Have Been Associated With Avandia?

Avandia has been linked to two types of edema (swelling or accumulation of fluid). Peripheral edema is swelling of the extremities due to fluid buildup.  Macular is the swelling and protein buildup in the eye area.  People who have taken Avandia have reported one or both types of edemas.  The edemas have been linked to congestive heart failure.  Studies suggest that there is a 43% increase in having a heart attack in people who have taken Avandia than the general population.

In addition to heart problems, Avandia has been linked to the following adverse medical conditions:

  • Blurred vision
  • Decreased visual acuity
  • Liver problems
  • Weight gain
  • Jaundice
  • Hypoglycemia

What Are My Rights If I Have Taken Avandia And Suffered Side Effects?

Given the fact that GlaxoSmithKline was aware of many of Avandia's side effects and did not act to immediately recall Avandia from the market, there appears to be significant culpability on the part of the manufacturer.  Depending on when you were prescribed, Avandia, you may also have a potential cause of action against the individual doctor or clinic.  

If you you a loved one has suffered from an injury since taking Avandia, you may contact our office for a free consultation and to learn your rights.  All consultations are kept confidential and there is no obligation on your part.  Please use the contact form or call, toll-free (888) 424-5757 to speak with our Avandia lawyers day or night.

Here is the May 21, 2007 FDA Safety Alert on Avandia.

Is There A Double Standard For Nursing Home Safety?

Does the government turn a blind eye to the large elderly and disabled population living in nursing homes?  Why does the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) specifically not reimburse hospitals for 10 'reasonably preventable' conditions related to improper care when nursing homes continue to provide the same inadequate care without reprocussion?

Steve Gold, at the JF Activist blog raises these issues in his recent post, 'Stop Paying Nursing Homes That Injure Elderly and Disabled People.'  Steve points out that as (CMS) has begun the crackdown on hospital safety, nursing homes continue to receive poor marks in national surveys.  In 1998, 81% of nursing homes were cited for at least one deficiency during CMS inspections.  By 2001, the number of nursing homes cited for deficiencies had risen to 89%.  In the most recent CMS survey, in 2007, the percentage of nursing homes receiving violations has increased to 91%.

Even more outrageous is the increase in 'immediate jeopardy' and 'actual harm' violations--the most serious-- handed to nursing homes by CMS.  The percentages of 'immediate jeopardy' violations has risen from 1.4% in 1998, 2.3% in 2001, to 17% in 2007.  To give people an idea of what these safety violations entail, Gold cites 2007 CMS OSCAR data:

  • 19.1% of nursing facilities had residents with avoidable pressure sores, and the nursing facilities received deficiencies for failing to meet the federal standard.  Up from 17.2% in 2001.
  • 11.8% of nursing facilities imposed physical restraints on residents for purposes of discipline or convenience and not required by the residents' medical symptoms, and they received deficiencies for this category.  Up from 11.0% in 2001.
  • 19.2% of nursing facilities had failed to prevent incontinence in residents and to restore bladder functioning as much as possible to residents, and the nursing facilities received deficiencies. Up from 12.0% in 2001.
  • 7.0% of nursing facilities failed to provide residents with acceptable nutrition to maintain their body weight, and the nursing facilities received deficiencies.  Down from 8.4% in 2001.
  • 37.9% of nursing facilities failed to ensure residents with environments "free of accident hazards" to "prevent unexpected and unintended injury," and the facilities received deficiency citations.  Up from 22.1% in 2001.
  • 6.6% of nursing facilities failed to provide residents with appropriate range of motion services to those people who required such services, and the nursing facilities received deficiencies.  Down from 8.1% in 2001.
  • 16.6% of nursing facilities failed to promote residents' care in a manner and in an environment that maintains or enhances the residents' dignity and respect for the individual resident, and the nursing facilities received deficiencies for violating the federal standard.  Down from 17.3% in 2001.

Gold rightly feels that there is a double standard being applied to elderly and disabled nursing home residents.  Most of the safety problems would never be tolerated in a hospital setting, yet we continue to allow them to occur nursing homes.  Until our society puts a premium on helping the elderly, nursing home residents will not get the rights and safety they deserve.  It is unfortunate that our culture turns their head from the elderly and their living conditions.  If any of the above safety problems occurred in a nursery school people would be out in the streets in rage.  Until then, let watch the annual safety violations escalate. 

The JF Activist blog is published by The American Association of People with Disabilities (AAPD).  AAPD is the largest national nonprofit cross-disability member organization in the United States, dedicated to ensuring economic self-sufficiency and political empowerment for the more than 50 million Americans with disabilities. AAPD works in coalition with other disability organizations for the full implementation and enforcement of disability nondiscrimination laws, particularly the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990 and the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.

Four Central Illinois Nursing Homes Cited For Negligent Care

On the heels of the recent Department of Health and Human Services report which demonstrated safety problems at virtually every nursing every nursing home across the country, recent article reports that Central Illinois is no different.  In 2008, four nursing homes in Peoria County, Illinois, were cited for negligent treatment of their residents. The Illinois Department of Public Health has cited Bel-Wood Nursing Home, Sharon Health Care Willows,  Manor Court of Peoria and Rosewood Care Center  for negligent patient care.  

Below is a summary of the incidents from the above Peoria County, Illinois nursing homes:

  • Bel-Wood Nursing Home: received citation for not reporting one resident's mysterious leg bruise.
  • Sharon Health Care Willows: was cited for not reporting several incidents , Including one staff member's aggressive intervention, and one resident's fall.
  • Rosewood Care Center: cited for failing to report one woman's fall from a toilet.  A report states was related to her death.
  • Manor Court of Peoria: was cited for failing to take a key preventative measure relating to patient safety, failing to conduct background checks on two nursing aides they hired earlier this year.

While nursing home administrators may feel like they are wrongfully targeted by state authorities, the investigations hopefully catch potentially dangerous situations before actual harm to the residents occurs.  Nursing home inspectors are the last line of defense for vulnerable nursing home residents. As IDPH Marketing Director, Melaney Arnold, says “We are very stringent and want to make sure that we are protecting the public, the resident's health and safety."

In Illinois, any complaint of nursing home abuse or neglect may be reported to the Illinois Department of Public Health (800) 252-4343.

A New Low In Nursing Home Care: A Bedsore On The Head

This week my office was contacted by the family of a man who had a stage IV bedsore on his head.  The man was a resident at a well-known Chicago nurising home for several years.  Bedsores are caused by unrelieved pressure or friction on a patients body.  If left untreated, the bedsores can develop from a minor skin irritation to a major would quickly.  Due to their 'open' nature, bedsores can easily become infected.  Bedsores are graded according to their severity, I, II, III and IV, with a stage IV being the most severe.

What makes this situation uniquely horrific is that bedsores generally develop in areas of the body where pressure relief is not always possible-- the buttocks, back or heels.  Because most nursing home residents lay in bed with pillows and and propped up for meals and washings, development of a bedsore on the head is a particularly frightening finding.

The development of a bedsore on the head essentially screams out the fact that this nursing home could care less about this person.  Even though this resident was bed-bound and fed through a feeding tube, the development of a pressure sore on his head should have been noticed if at no other time than when the staff changed the sheets?  This facility should be ashamed of itself and every person who works there.  I will keep you posted as to developments in this incident involving a new low in nursing home care.

Nursing Home Workers Charged In Connection To Withholding Oxygen To Resident

Two nursing home workers in Arkansas are facing criminal charges, manslaughter and elder neglect, following the 2007 death of a resident.  The charges stem from failing to plug an oxygen line into the wall spigot for an oxygen-dependent patient.  By the time the workers came back to check-in on the patient her hands were blue and cold.   

Upon learning of the resident's condition, the workers told the nursing director, but failed to alert the resident's family or physician that her condition was related to a lack of oxygen.  Authorities believe that withholding the circumstances surrounding the lack of oxygen to the resident's physician contributed to resident's death.  Read more about this incident involving nursing home neglect here.

My take is that of course mistakes--no matter how serious--happen and will continue.  The real problem in this situation is that the staff failed to catch this mistake before the resident's injury became irreversible.  Had a simple observation plan been in place, this situation could have been avoided.

Nursing Home Injury Laws: Arkansas

Never Event #4: Catheter Associated Urinary Tract Infections

Catheter related urinary tract infections are the most frequently encountered infection amongst people in nursing homes.  Generally, the longer a catheter is in place, the more likely an infection will develop.  According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), infection rates range from 1% to 5% after a single brief catheterization to virtually 100% rate of infection for long-term catheter uses. 

The urinary tract is composed of the kidneys and urethra.  As a rule, the 'higher up' the infection, the more serious it is.  A lower urinary tract infection affects the urethra and bladder and can usually be treated easily with antibiotics.  An infection in the upper urinary tract is more severe and affects the kidneys (pyelonephritis) and requires extensive medical treatment.  Once a urinary tract infection reaches the kidneys, it must be closely monitored or it may spread to other areas of the body. An advanced urinary tract infection may result in kidney failure and death.

What are the symptoms of a catheter associated urinary tract infection?

  • Painful urination
  • Tenderness above the pubic bone
  • Decreased appetite
  • Inbalance, frequent falls
  • Increased heartbeat

If there is such a high rate of infection, why is a catheter associated urinary tract infection on the 'never list'?

Most urinary tract infections are preventable with the implementation of basic sanitation.  Further, upper urinary tract infections are preventable with early detection and treatment.  Below are safeguards recommended by the CDC:

  • Provide education to hospital and nursing home staff on proper catheter insertion technique
  • Only catheterize when necessary
  • Wash hands
  • Use sterile equipment
  • Use closed drainage bags
  • Take regular urine samples
  • Observe the color, clarity, and smell of draining urine
  • Keep residents with urinary tract infections separate from other non-infected residents

As you can see, most of the prevention guidelines are extremely basic,  There is no excuse for facilities that fail to implement of urinary tract infection prevention techniques.  

 

 

 

 

 

Never Event #3: Poorly Controlled Blood Sugar, Hyperglycemia & Hypoglycemia

Medicare has determined that complications associated with poorly controlled blood sugar should be included on the 'never list' as they are so easily avoidable that the costs of the treatment should not be permitted to be submitted to CMS for reimbursement.  In 2007, there were 14,929 reported cases of poorly controlled blood sugar amongst diabetics in hospitals.  

 

 

Hyperglycemia

Hyperglycemia develops when there is too much sugar in the blood (glucose > 180mg/dl). Hyperglycemia may be caused by skipping insulin does, infection or illness.  Prolonged hyperglycemia can result in infection, slow-healing cuts and sores, vision problems, nerve damage in arms and legs, chronic constipation and death.

Hypoglycemia

Hypoglycemia develops when blood sugar levels fall (glucose < 70mg/dl).  Like hyperglycemia, hypoglycemia may develop when insulin is not timely administered or if the dosage is too high. Hypoglycemia may lead to serious medical complications such as coma or death.

Importance of Monitoring Diabetic Patients

Residents of hospitals and nursing homes with diabetes must be monitored on a regular basis. Proper monitoring of diabetics should consist of not only monitoring their blood sugar levels and diet, but the medical staff must also keep track of how the residents look and behave.  Special attention should be paid to residents who experience: frequent urination, weight loss, fatigue, unusual aches or vision problems.

If you or a loved one experienced an episode of hyperglycemia or hypoglycemia during a stay at a hospital or nursing home contact an experienced medical malpractice lawyer to learn your rights.

Never Event #2: Infection In Central Venous Catheters

 The second most frequently encountered 'never event' is an infection from a central venous catheter.  Infections due to improperly maintained and inplanted central venous catheters accounted for 29,536 cases in hospitals in 2007.  A central venous catheter is a tube usually inserted in an arm or chest and threaded through a vein until it reaches a large vein close to the heart.  Central venous catheters are used to administer medication, supply nutrition or blood products.  

There are three main types of central venous catheters:

  • PICC Line: A 'peripherally inserted central catheter.'  PICC's are the most common type of central venous catheter accounting for more than 50% of the vascular catherizations because it may be inserted relatively easily.  PICC's are inserted into a vein in the arm as opposed to the neck or chest.
  • Tunneled Catheter: A surgically inserted catheter in the neck or chest and is passed under the skin.  Only the end of the catheter is visible through the skin.  Passing the catheter under the skin allow people greater mobility and helps the catheter stay in place.
  • Inplanted Port Catheter: Similar to the tunneled catheter, but the entire catheter is left under the skin.  Medication must be injected through the skin and into the catheter.

More than 40% of bloodstream infections are accounted for in people with central venous catheters. An estimated 1% to 5% of people with central venous catheters who get an infections die from them. In order to reduce the likelihood of infection, the following should be done:

  • Use sterile technique when working with a person who has a central venous catheter.
  • Clean the exposed area of the catheter on a regular basis.
  • Dressings should be changed at a minimum of every week.
  • The catheter should be flushed regularly.
  • The exposed end of the catheter should be routinely check for inflammation and discoloration--the early signs of a potential infection.

Basic maintenance and observation should be part of all hospital and nursing home patients routine.  If you have acquired a blood infection during your hospital or nursing home stay, do not assume that your condition was inevitable.  For more information on infections of central vascular catheters this is a useful article.

Never Event #1: Hospital Falls & Trauma

Falls in trauma top the list of preventable medical conditions in hospitals, accounting for 193,566 incidents in 2007.  Falls in hospitals (and similarly in nursing homes) are deemed to be preventable by Medicare because with proper fall/risk assessments and staff assistance most falls in hospital could be avoided.  A number of factors should be addressed by a hospital to determine if a person is at risk for falls:

  • Medication that may effect balance or coordination
  • Does the person normally use an assistive device like a walker or cane?  If so, one should be provided by the facility at all times.
  • Age.  Older residents have a far greater risk of falling than their younger counterparts
  • Is the person able to use the bathroom themselves?  If not, regular assistance should be provided by the staff.

In a recent study by researchers at Washington University in St. Louis, patients were injured in 42% of falls occurring in the hospital.  Hospital patients were seriously injured in 8% of the falls with head trauma or fractures.  The study also determined that the people most likely to sustain a serious fall-related injury were those on their way to or in the bathroom.  

In addition to determining patients who are at high risk for falling, hospitals should take precautions to minimize the likelihood of falls due to sloppiness or inadequate staffing.  In order to assure resident falls are minimized hospitals should make sure the following in done:

  • Remove clutter from floor.  
  • Remove improperly fitting slippers and other clothing.
  • Keep bed rails up when patients are sleeping.
  • Provide adequate staff and equipment when transferring into and out of bed.
  • Install handrails in areas where patients need stability.
  • Keep call lights within reach of residents in bed at all times.  Residents can request assistance easily.
  • Lock wheels on wheelchairs and beds when transferring patients.

If a fall occurred during a hospitalization, do not assume that the fall resulted from an unforeseeable condition.  There is a good likelihood that the hospital should of identified the patients likelihood of falling and taken precautions. 

Medicare No Longer To Pay For 'Reasonably Prevenatable' Medical Errors

As of October 1, 2008 Medicare is no longer reimbursing hospitals for reasonably preventable medical errors.  The medical facilities will similarly no longer be able to charge patients directly for medical care resulting in errors.  Called 'never events'--because the medical errors were never intended to occur, the below is a list of the never events and well as their reported frequency in 2007.  The below chart was published in The New York Times article on 'never events.'

We at The Chicago Nursing Home Law Blog applaud this important development towards improving patient safety.  We will soon be highlighting each of the ten 'never events' with individual posts. 

Who Should Manage Administration Of Medication?

The discussion on administration of medication at assisted living facilities at Inside Assisted Living, caught my attention.  Inside Assisted Living is an extremely useful blog dedicated to helping residents and their families transition into assisted living facilities.  A reader of the blog asked:

'Ryan, my parents are now in an Assisted Living Community. I’ve been told that they must turn over administration of their meds to the Nurse. Problem is, that there is constantly problems with the meds given by the nurse, ie. meds from another patient, not given at proper time, cannot identify the pill, not all prescriptions given. They tell me that this is a Federally mandated law that my parents cannot self administer, is this true?'

Ryan, the blog administrator gives some excellent advice when addressing this frequently encountered situation dealing with medication errors.  If the resident of an assisted living facility is capable of administering medication, they should generally be able to do so.  I must agree, with Ryan that once a facility takes on an important responsibility, such as the administering medication they must do so in a safe manner

If an assisted living facility or nursing home is dispensing the wrong medication or is administering the doses at improper intervals, the situation should be brought to the attention of the facility administrator and / or the state department of public health.

Studies have shown that medication errors occur with up to 50% of nursing home and long-term care residents.  The following are important criteria to evaluate to assure your loved one is the the recipient of a medication error.

Review each medication with a physician to determine its necessity

  • Make sure the list of medications is complete
  • Identify the condition for which each medication is prescribed
  • Determine the potential for any drug vs. drug interactions
  • Determine potential for any drug vs. disease interactions
  • Can the drug regimen be simplified?
  • Are there any new, safer drugs available to substitute with current medication?
  • Is it possible to discontinue any medication? 

New medication tips

  • Is the diagnosis correct?
  • Can the condition be treated without medication?
  • Can a lower dosage be used?
  • Could the symptoms be related to another medication?
  • Can one drug be used to treat multiple conditions?

Inappropriate medication use

  • Don't try to treat every condition. It is impossible to treat every physical condition
  • Don't try to treat the side effects of medications
  • Try to have one physician prescribe all medications
  • Make sure each all physicians involved in a patients treatment are aware of each other

Bottom line is that given the frequency of medication errors and the serious medical complications that may arise from their complications it is best to speak up immediately if you suspect even a minor deviation from the physician prescribed medical protocol.

Nursing Home & Hospital Surveyor Blog

I just started going throug this infomative blog Nurisng Home & Hospital Surveyor Blog.  The blog is written by a nurse and nursing home investigator.  Just looking at the most recent post, I can tell that this site is going to have a ton of valuable information related to nursing home care.  I will report more info soon.

Video: New York Nursing Home Worker Caught On Tape

 A video has surfaced regarding a recent blog post that shows nurses at a New York nursing home abusing and neglecting their residents.  The use of video camera has lead to 26 arrests of nursing home workers.  It is scary to think what other criminal acts these nurses may have done in the course of their employment that WAS NOT caught on tape.

 

New York Nursing Home Nurses Charged With Criminal Neglect

Four employees of the Medford Multicare Center for Living in Suffolk, NY have been charged with criminal neglect and falsifying business records.  New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo announced the charges following six weeks of video surveillance at the nursing home in 2007.  The nurses are accused of failing to move and turn over a patient for up to seven hours at a time, denying the patient water and left him sitting in his own waste.  Felony charges were also filed relating to falsifying medical records claiming they administered heart medication when the nursing home was actually had the medication out of stock.  The nurses were released without bail and are due back in court on March 20. Read more about this case involving alleged nursing home neglect here.

Failing to turn a patient and skipping a dosage of medication may seem like minor variations and have little impact on patient care.  The reality is that these seemingly minor deficiencies can have tragic results.  Failing to clean and turn a bed bound patient can lead to the rapid development pf pressure sores.  Similarly, failing to administer medication may result in other medical problems.  Once again, perhaps 'hidden cameras' should become the norm in nursing homes to both protect patients and vindicate wrongfully charged nursing home staff.

Nursing Shortage Is A Crisis

Another crisis is about to grip our country.  As we attempt to get a over our finances, a nursing shortage is beginning to effect patient care and seems to be a problem that will plague us for many years to come.  Nurse Tom reports that nursing shortages in hospitals and nursing homes are an ever increasing problem for patient safety.  The safety problems created by under-staffing have become an even bigger problem for hospitals has they can no longer receive Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement for event determined to be preventable or commonly referred to as 'never events.'

How extensive is the nursing shortage?

In 2007, a survey completed by the American Hospital Association found that hospitals require an additional 116,000 RN's to fill immediate vacancies. Statistics from Flotsam and Jetsam Blog report current nursing shortages at 14% of hospitals where there is a severe vacancy.  By 2025 the nursing shortage is expected to increase to 500,000 RN's- the most highly trained nurses.

Increased liability risk for hospitals and nursing homes

"As I see it, nursing is the most important area to focus on when it comes to preventing hospital mishaps," according to Tom Sharon, creator of the Legal Nurse Consultant website.  Hospital Corporation of America is currently facing a class-action lawsuit claiming the company engaged in systematic under-staffing of RN's throughout all of its hospitals.  The lawsuit claims that the 'systematic under-staffing' places patients at increased risk for complications such as infections, bedsores and death. 

Nurses are on the front lines of responding to patient needs.  If nurses are not there to attend to patients it is no secret that serious medical problems may go unattended.  A new wave of lawsuits is being filed against hospitals for under-staffing.  It is increasingly becoming not a question of what was done improperly, but a question as to what medical treatment was not provided.

A cure for the nursing shortage

There is no immediate cure for the nurse shortage problem.  The Registered Nurse Safe Staffing Act, recently introduced federal legislation, would ensure that each hospital generate a staffing system that ensures appropriate number of registered nurses on each shift and in each unit of the hospital.  

Other ideas include using volunteers to help with basic tasks such as monitoring patients in waiting areas and hospital rooms to make sure nothing happens while they are recovering form a procedure or waiting to see a doctor.  As nurse Tom says, 'There's no skill to that. Just sit there and watch to prevent falls."

The nursing shortage's impact on nursing home

Residents of nursing home will likely see a bigger impact that other medical care recipients.  Many skilled nurses who currently work in nursing home will be sucked out of those facilities and into higher paying nursing positions in hospitals.  A nurse in a hospital may earn several times what the pay rate for nurses is in a nursing home.  Unfortunately, until a priority is placed on providing quality nursing home care, there will likely be a continued correlation between inadequately staffed facilities in incidents involving nursing home injury and neglect.

Do Lawsuits Help Or Hinder Nursing Home Care?

 

Important information for nursing home residents and their families. Discussion of bedsores, neglect, abuse, falls and resident rights.

 

Eyes On Living had an interesting blog post recently 'Florida Nursing Home Abuse Lawsuits Increasing Thanks To Aggressive Lawyers.'  The article is a little tongue in cheek with respect to how attorneys want to help victims out of the kindness of their own heart, but the author does acknowledge that lawsuits filed in states with a substantial elderly population has actually improved the quality of nursing home care.

This got me thinking about the impact of nursing home litigation has on the overall care received by nursing home residents.  Do nursing home lawsuits have an impact on the quality of nursing home care?  The answer, in my eyes, is a resounding 'yes'. 

Sure, we all hear about juries awarding people with superficial injuries large awards and the recipients going out and spending their awards on lavish things.  The reality of the overriding majority of nursing home injury cases, it that many of these people have been downright neglected or abused and their lives have been forever changed by the acts of nursing homes for the worse.

For many victims of nursing home abuse and neglect their golden years have become anything but happy and satisfying.  Too often, the lives of seniors have been cut short or painfully altered by the acts of facilities that were intended to care for them.  

The purpose of the Nursing Home Care Act in Illinois is similar to laws in place in Florida and Texas--it is intended to help residents of nursing homes and other long-term care facilities from being taken advantage of and ultimately injured.  These laws also allows for attorneys to recover their legal fees if they are successful in their case against the nursing home.

Bad nursing homes are being forced to change their ways.  Many facilities that once cut corners with respect to patient safety can longer do so or they face claims and lawsuits for serious injury.  If improving patient safety and care means that some facilities are forced to close their doors, in the long run we all will be better off.  

Excuse me while I go look look for a billboard...

Elder Abuse Suspected At Assisted Living Facility

The Los Angeles Times recently reported on a story involving potential abuse of an Alzheimer's patient at an assisted living facility in California.  Four employees of the Calabasas assisted-living facility were recently arrested on suspicion of elder abuse stemming from the death of a resident last year.  Elder abuse charges follow on a report from an anonymous whistle blower who was an employee at the facility.  The whistle blower told the victim's family that a co-worker had punched the resident in his eye and attempted to suffocate the man shortly before his death.  The allegations have been confirmed by the sheriff's department who have an employee of the facility in custody.

The alleged elder abuse victim and wife from LA Time

Anytime there are multiple employees involved in a crime or pattern of abuse, others are aware of the behavior.  In this case another employee tipped the family and authorities to the abuse.  How long did this employee know the abusive behavior was going on?   How many other employees were aware of this?  Could this incident have been prevented?

Statute Of Limitations For Bringing A Nursing Home Lawsuit

 "How long do I have to bring a case against a negligent nursing home?"

The answer depends on where the incident took place.  The time to bring a lawsuit against the a nursing home is governed by the statute of limitations where the incident occurred.  Most states have specific statute of limitations for personal injury and nursing home cases.  The statute of limitations can vary tremendously by jurisdiction.  Some states have statute of limitations as short as one year from the date of the injury and other states permit a cause of action to be brought up to eight years from the date of the injury.  Statute of limitations are strictly interpreted.  If you fail to bring a lawsuit within the statute of limitations you will be forever barred from recovery.

This underlies the importance of contacting an experienced nursing home attorney shortly after an incident occurs.  Further, in many situations it is important to file a lawsuit far earlier than the statute of limitations allow in order to determine all of potentially responsible parties.

Resource:

Nursing Home Injury Laws

New Version Of Nursing Home Transparency Act

A new version of the Nursing Home Transparency Act and Quality Act of Care has been proposed in the House of Representatives by Pete Stark (D- CA) and Jan Schakowsky (D- IL).  The new version of the legislation is a modification of an earlier bill proposed by Senator Herb Kohl (D- WI) and Charles Grassley (R- IA) earlier this year.  The new version contains more stringent requirements for nursing homes and other long-term care facilities.  Specifically, the new bill contains additional provisions for quality assurance and improvement demonstration program.  According to Representative Stark,

"As the government pays for 60% of spending on nursing homes annually, with 80 percent of residents supported by public funds at any time, we have the responsibility to hold the homes accountable for the quality of care they provide."

Not surprisingly, The American Health Care Association (AHCA), which represents many nursing homes and long-term care facilities opposed the bill calling it "highly subjective, inconsistent and an inaccurate assessment of quality.

With more than 90% of nursing homes across the U.S. cited for violations--many of which that directly impact patient safety, the new bill is not only timely, but essential to assure some level of decent quality care for nursing home residents. Read more about the proposed version of the Nursing Home Transparency Act here.

 

Pressure Sore Video

A client emailed me this disturbing You Tube video on pressure sores.  The video is graphic, but demonstrates the horrific pressure sores that may develop without proper nursing care.  The video has photos of:

As the narrator says, if you have a pressure sore, it is likely the result of neglect.  If this pressure sore developed in a nursing home, long-term care facility or hospital, you likely have a case against them for improper care and are entitled to damages for the resulting medical treatment and pain and suffering amongst other legal rights.

Bed Sore FAQ

Nursing Home Injury Laws: Bed Sores, Pressure Sores, Decubitus Ulcers, Pressure Ulcers

California To Cut Back On Nursing Home Inspections

California Governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger recently signed a state budget for California that cuts funding for local ombudsman programs.  Ombudsman programs investigate complaints of nursing home abuse and nursing home neglect and provide training for nursing home staff on how to prevent abuse.

The budget cuts will make it harder to respond to nursing home complaints and protect the rights of residents in long-term care facilities, according to Kathleen Johnson of Advocacy Inc.  Advocacy Inc. operates an ombudsman program in two counties in California and oversees approximately 2,500 nursing home residents in 44 facilities.  All of the facilities in the two counties have been cited for deficiencies during inspections.  Johnson goes on to say,

"The governor makes it clear that the most vulnerable and least visible population in our state does not merit protection, advocacy respect or a voice."

As the credit crisis on Wall Street spreads to Main Street, look for similar nursing home-related budget cuts in your state.  As Ms. Johnson points out, many nursing home related budget cuts are first in line because residents are tucked away out of the publics' view.  Read more about this potential problem for California nursing home residents here.

New Medicare Website For Caregivers

The Elder Law Prof Blog prepared by Professor Kim Dayton, Director of the Center for Elder Justice and Policy at the William Mitchell College of Law, recently reported on a new service on the Medicare website for elder caregivers.  The new Medicare website provides useful information to help home caregivers with questions such as:

  • How to enroll in Medicare
  • What doctors take Medicare?
  • Are there alternatives to nursing homes?
  • What billing forms need to be completed?
  • How to choose a nursing home

Today there are more than 44 million Americans (one out of five) provide daily care for a chronically ill or aging loved one, friend, or neighbor.  The value of the care services is valued at $350 billion annually, according to AARP.

State Of Ohio To Take Over Nursing Home Inspections Following Dangerous Conditions

Following on the well publicized nursing home violations at the Westside Health Care Center and The Terrace at Westside, the Cincinnati Health Department has been stripped of its ability to license and inspect nursing homes.

Cincinnati City Council members determined that that city health inspectors failed to protect some of the community's most frail residents. The city health department's oversight duties will be turned over to the state authorities.

In March, a surprise inspection found dangerous conditions in the nursing home including: 

Nursing Home Facility Problems

  • Fire doors tied shut
  • Mold on walls
  • Cigarette butts in walkways
  • Soiled mattresses
  • Roach infestation
  • Uncleaned vomit

 Nursing Home Staff Violations

  • Allowing residents to smoke near oxygen tanks
  • Storing medication improperly
  • No psychological training for staff caring for residents with psychological problems
  • No first aid training
  • No fire drill training
  • 20% medication error rate

The city counsel should be applauded for putting the important responsibility of nursing home inspections in the hands of more capable people.  Obviously, with the violations described above, many serious violations slipped through the cracks.  More information about this nursing home inspection can be found here.

Barbaric Treatment Lands Nursing Home Employees In Criminal Court

<META name="y_key" content="c00b2f7a0c782aaf" >

The criminal case against two Portland nursing home employees gave me chills.  This case goes beyond nursing home neglect and enters the realm of nursing home cruelty. According to reports, a nursing director is being charged with two charges of criminal mistreatment and a certified nursing assistant (CNA) is being charged with reckless endangerment for their inaction following the fall-related injury to a resident at the Gateway Care and Rehabilitation Center.

The nursing home employees allegedly waited five days before sending a 59-year-old resident to the hospital for medical treatment for her broken legs sustained in a fall.  The nursing home resident apparently fell while being transferred from her wheelchair to her bed with a lift. 

The nursing home staff tried to hide the incident from the resident's family.  Federal and state nursing home regulations were ignored as no incident report was completed following the fall.  Despite the fact that the nursing home resident was screaming in pain and nurses could hear popping sounds coming from the badly broken legs, no medical treatment was provided.  After five days of living in pain the resident was taken to a hospital where she died.

These criminal charges against the individual nursing home employees are separate from a lawsuit for wrongful death that the estate of the deceased woman is entitled to bring.  If these claims of nursing home neglect prove to be true the nursing home and its owners should be held fully responsible for fostering an environment where nursing home employees hold a code of silence to protect each other.

Improper Transfer Leads To Fall & Ultimately Death Of Rehab Patient

Even the best facilities occasionally provide bad treatment to their residents.  A wrongful death lawsuit has been recently filed against Schwab Rehabilitation Hospital, a nationally recognized rehab center in Chicago on behalf of the family of a deceased resident.  The family carefully selected Schwab as a rehabilitation center for their loved one's physical therapy and rehab training following the amputation of a leg. 

Unfortunately, even this well respected facility, failed to provide basic care for an elderly man's needs.  When the man was admitted to Schwab, the physicians ordered that the man be transferred in and out of his wheelchair with the use of a mechanical lift and two staff members.  The day after his admission a CNA ignored the physicians' orders and attempted to transfer the man into his wheelchair herself.  In the process the man fell and fractured his hip and femur

Like many physically fragile elderly, the injury lead to a spiral of deteriorating medical problems.  Following surgery at nearby Mt. Sinai Hospital, on his hip and femur fractures, the man became immobilized and developed a pressure ulcer on his sacrum.  Additionally, the man was diagnosed with sepsis, pneumonia, and respiratory failure.  Within three months of the fall, the man died.

The man's family filed a lawsuit against Schwab for negligent rehabilitation treatment.  The lawsuit was filed in Cook county Circuit Court.  Read more about this poor treatment at this well known Chicago rehabilitation hospital here.

This case demonstrates that a facilities reputation does not guarantee quality medical treatment.  Incidents at well-regarded medical facilities may occur with less frequency, but are just as devastating as incidents occurring at facilities with lesser reputations.  This case also highlights the importance of staff following physician orders.  If the CNA had simply followed the instructions set forth by the treating physicians this sad incident could have been avoided.

In this case, an investigation conducted by the Illinois Department of Public Health confirmed the care this elderly man received was improper.

About Jonathan Rosenfeld

Photo of Jonathan Rosenfeld

Jonathan Rosenfeld is a lawyer who represents people injured in nursing homes and long-term care facilities.   Jonathan has represented...

Read More

Subscribe

Add this blog to your feeds or subscribe by email using the form below

Concerned about a loved one? Talk with an attorney today.

Bed Sore FAQs

Frequently asked questions on bed sore prevention, treatment and legal rights of those who have been neglected.

View FAQs